Chief Seattle Address Essay

Chief Seattle's 1854 Oration Was It True?

Chief Seattle, leader of the Duwamish tribe, was author of the famous speech to Washington Governor Stevens upon his arrival to Seattle in 1854. However, many doubt Chief Seattle's speech to have taken place. There is little credible evidence available to back up the existence of the speech with the exception of a newspaper article written by a Doctor Henry A. Smith. The article, titled "Chief Seattle's Speech," was published in the "Seattle Sunday Star" on October 27th, 1887. If Doctor Smith was witness to Chief Seattle's epic speech, he was the sole translator. How are we to know that translation faults and liberations were not made by Doctor Smith? The Duwamish language was not a written language, having no alphabet, thus no official record or writing could have been made. For these reasons, it is highly probable Chief Seattle's Oration of 1854 never existed.

The first and only published account of Chief Seattle's Oration was written in the "Seattle Sunday Star" on October 27th, 1887. The author of the article, Doctor Henry Smith, was said to have been a witness at the speech and served as a translator for Chief Seattle; however, no official document of this account exists in any historical archive. Chief Seattle's speech has been widely cited in numerous books and documents, but every citation leads back to Doctor Smith's article. Therefore, the only proof available that this speech ever occurred is the newspaper article dating back to 1887 from this one source.

If we are to...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

'It was not the weakness of the nationalists but the strengths of the colonial rulers that led to the failure of the nationalist movements in SEA before WWII.' How far is this true?

3039 words - 12 pages On the eve of World War II, despite much effort, the nationalist movements were unable to make any headway and failed. The failure of the nationalist movements can be attributed to various factors. Nationalist organizations were saddled by disunity and the failure to win mass support. On top of the weakness of the nationalists, external factors including the complex demographic makeup hindered the nationalist in achieving success. Most...

Indians and there Sacred Lands Essay

1029 words - 4 pages Question: Does the white man attempt to care for or respect the earth?Claim: Indians share common thoughts on different aspects of the earth on how the white man does not care for or respect it.From the beginning of time, we have been in confrontation with the American Indians. In most of the...

Oration Defined by Cicero

1645 words - 7 pages The social tendencies of humans and primates in general stay ingrained into our DNA. We cannot escape certain aspects of our social natures such as feelings of compassion or hatred for others and innate emotional reactions to stimuli. Remnants of the tribal mindset in human psyche allows proverbial "queen bees" to harvest power. No matter how hard we try, our hereditary wiring rejects any attempts at ignoring the draw of a charismatic person,...

Examining how Brutus and Mark Anthony Utilise Language to Manipulate the Audience in Act 3 Scene 2 of Julius Caesar

2072 words - 8 pages Examining how Brutus and Mark Anthony Utilise Language to Manipulate the Audience in Act 3 Scene 2 of Julius Caesar This essay will scrutinize and analyse two speeches from Julius Caesar; firstly Brutus's funeral oration and Mark Anthony's response in Act 3 Scene 2. Brutus as a conspirator against Caesar addresses the audience to justify himself along with his other conspirator's actions whilst Mark Anthony speaks in...

Neo-Aristotelian Analysis of Chief Sagoyewatha’s Speech to Missionaries; 1805

3232 words - 13 pages Bertsch 1 A Neo-Aristotelian Analysis of Chief Sagoyewatha's ("Red Jacket") Oration to Christian Missionaries, 1805 By Kevin Bertsch Prepared for Professor Mary Walch COM 3343; CRN 10617 in Rhetorical Criticism Spring 2014 Semester Bertsch 2 A Neo-Aristotelian Analysis of Chief Sagoyewatha's...

The Funeral Oration

1273 words - 5 pages Delaney AdamsSpring 2014HIS111 deMayoApril 8, 2014"The Funeral Oration" was a eulogy originally spoken by Pericles amidst the Athenian war on Sparta in 431 B.C.E. that was later recalled, and recorded for posterity by the famous Athenian historian Thucydides. Pericles, the orator and original writer of "The Funeral Oration," was a...

Who Wants to be Next in Line

1683 words - 7 pages WHO WANTS TO BE NEXT IN LINE? In Greek words translated as I obey actually mean I get myself persuaded. For a man there is perhaps always something a little shameful about obeying someone - as if allowing yourself to be persuaded is a thing a warrior or hero would be embarrassed to find himself happening to him. The common goal of the Periclean Age was...

The Book of Courtier Baldesar Castiglione

1010 words - 4 pages The Book of Courtier Baldesar Castiglione The Renaissance was a period prompted by the rebirth in classical culture. As classical culture resurfaced, it gradually awakened and inspired the human soul, leading to tremendous development in individuality. Humans took a gigantic stride away from barbarianism and distinguished themselves by focusing on intellectual progress. The capabilities of human nature unfolded as man studied all things...

Thycydides and The Peloponnesian War

2526 words - 10 pages The perspective that Thucydides took to write History of the Peloponnesian War gave his work, on a first read, the impression that his opinion was removed to provide an objective analysis of the destruction of the greatness of Athens over the period of the war. He began with a “medical history” of how humanity structured the first societies based on the interplay between fear, interest, and honor. Then, progressed to how war devolved the great...

The Golden Age of Athens

1340 words - 5 pages Greece’s Golden Age can be defined as a time of flourishing. Athens made the important decision of splitting itself from Sparta, who they constantly differed with. “It is from this split that the Athenian Empire was created” (Hunt 80). This split illustrates the certainty that the Athenians possessed in terms of creating a better nation. Athens developed an empire because democracy was expensive. In order for democracy to be created, you need an...

Analysis of Sojouner Truth's Slave Narrative "Ar'nt I a Woman"?

644 words - 3 pages Analysis of Sojourner Truth's Slave Narrative Ar'nt I a Woman? Although Sojourner Truth never learned to read or write she still was able to contribute in the frantic fight for the civil rights of African Americans, in the south, and women, in the north. The narrative Ar'nt I a Woman was spoken by Truth at a women's rights convention in Akron, Ohio, in 1851. Truth gave her speech against the wishes of the convention's participants, and as...

Chief Seattle, leader of the Duwamish tribe, was author of the famous speech to Washington Governor Stevens upon his arrival to Seattle in 1854. However, many doubt Chief Seattle’s speech to have taken place. There is little credible evidence available to back up the existence of the speech with the exception of a newspaper article written by a Doctor Henry A. Smith. The article, titled “Chief Seattle’s Speech,” was published in the “Seattle Sunday Star” on October 27th, 1887. If Doctor Smith was witness to Chief Seattle’s epic speech, he was the sole translator. How are we to know that translation faults and liberations were not made by Doctor Smith? The Duwamish language was not a written language, having no alphabet, thus no official record or writing could have been made. For these reasons, it is highly probable Chief Seattle’s Oration of 1854 never existed.

The first and only published account of Chief Seattle’s Oration was written in the “Seattle Sunday Star” on October 27th, 1887. The author of the article, Doctor Henry Smith, was said to have been a witness at the speech and served as a translator for Chief Seattle; however, no official document of this account exists in any historical archive. Chief Seattle’s speech has been widely cited in numerous books and documents, but every citation leads back to Doctor Smith’s article. Therefore, the only proof available that this speech ever occurred is the newspaper article dating back to 1887 from this one source.

If we are to give the benefit of the doubt to Doctor Henry Smith as having been witness a to this speech, who is to say the translation was correct? For all we know “Doctor” Henry A. Smith made up every word of the speech, nobody would know. Chief Seattle was known to have been illiterate, neither knowing how to read, write or speak English (McCarthy par. 12). His speech was presented in nice paragraph form, almost as if Chief Seattle was reading the address off a piece of paper, even though Chief Seattle could not read.

The Duwamish language had no alphabet, it could not be written, it was only spoken. There is no possible way Chief Seattle could have had anything to read from or look at while giving his speech to Governor Stevens. Due to these facts, no official record of the speech could exist. Yes, Doctor Smith could have written a near-perfect translation, but there is no evidence to suggest this. An account of the speech by the Duwamish tribe, or a copy of the speech in Duwamish, does not exist for anyone to refer to.

The man known as Chief Seattle existed, the Duwamish tribe existed, Doctor Smith existed, these are known FACTS. However, there is only but one written account by a Doctor Henry Smith that this Oration took place, and only one translator was said to have been at Chief Seattle’s Oration and that one man was a Doctor Henry A. Smith. The Duwamish tribe had no written language for an official copy of this speech to have taken place, and there is no reason for anyone to believe that Doctor Smith took an exact translation with no liberations added. For these reasons, Chief Seattle’s Oration of 1854 never existed.

Categories: 1

0 Replies to “Chief Seattle Address Essay”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *